Blog

Is Dave Ramsey Right?

Share this Post

Subscribe to our newsletter.

Is Dave Ramsey Right? His 12% Return and 8% Withdrawal Advice

Dave Ramsey is a household name when it comes to teaching finance. He gives a lot of advice on various financial topics, but should we take what he says to the bank?

In full disclosure, years ago I was part of Dave Ramsey’s SmartVestor Pro program. All that really meant is that my business was analyzed by Dave’s people, and I paid them a fee to be listed as a financial advisor on his website. I haven’t been part of the program for a long time, and even then I didn’t agree with everything Dave says — and here’s why you shouldn’t either.

Where Dave Ramsey is right: getting out of debt

When it comes to debt and debt reduction, I think Dave does an outstanding job. I may not agree with every little detail of his program, but if you stick with his program it will work. (If you are tempted to use your TSP to get there, read four reasons not to take a TSP loan first.) Where I don’t agree with him is in retirement planning.

Dave makes two big assumptions that I believe can be devastating to an individual’s retirement:

  • Plan on making a 12% return on your investments
  • Plan on taking a distribution from your investments of 8% per year

He is still making this case; in late 2023 he told his radio audience that an 8% withdrawal rate was safe, based on a 12% return minus about 4% for inflation (Thornburg, December 2023). If you read no further in this article know this – you SHOULD NOT count on either of these two assumptions in your retirement planning.

Why shouldn’t you count on a 12% return?

Simply put – because it isn’t realistic. According to the Dimensional Fund Advisors Matrix Book, large cap stocks averaged a 9.9% annual return from 1928 through 2017. During the same time small caps averaged 12.2%. I suppose it is possible to invest all of your money in small cap stocks — as Dave’s 12% figure would imply — but that isn’t a very responsible way to invest because it lacks diversification. Small cap stocks have been more volatile than large cap stocks in the past, therefore you are taking on more risk to invest in them.

Is an 8% withdrawal rate safe in retirement?

That is a great question, but the answer probably isn’t 8% as Ramsey suggests. Dave’s theory is that your investments will make 12%, you will take an 8% distribution, and your account balance will continue climbing by 4% a year.

That sounds great in theory, but the real world doesn’t work that way.

I can’t say that I have ever seen a business or retirement plan succeed based on a unicorn scenario. Most financial experts would tell you to plan on taking a 4% distribution from your assets in retirement. However, there have been many studies that show that a 5% or 6% distribution can work. I go deeper on this in should you withdraw 4% from your TSP?

How retirement withdrawal studies work

Let me explain what I mean by study. There are two common elements of most retirement studies: a time period of anywhere between 20 and 40 years, and a Monte Carlo analysis. The time period is important since most retirees want their assets to last throughout retirement. For some people a 20-year time period may be sufficient while others may need their assets to last for 40 years or more.

A Monte Carlo analysis is a tool that generates many random returns (usually 1,000 different trials). The reason that the random variables are needed is that returns on an investment don’t happen in a straight line. If you have a mutual fund that has averaged 12% a year, that doesn’t mean that it makes 12% every year, but is simply the average. It could be up 10% one year and down 30% the next year.

A Monte Carlo analysis does a good job of accounting for sequence of return risk. For example, if you retired at the end of 2007, you would have seen close to a 40% drop in your stock investments in 2008 (based on the returns of domestic and international indexes). Even a moderate exposure to stocks in 2008 could have been destructive to retirement plans, and especially one that is based on a 12% annual return and 8% withdrawals. On the opposite end, if you retired in 2009 you would have started retirement with a bull market that lasted until early 2020, which is an outstanding start to retirement.

There are a multitude of factors that need to be considered when determining your withdrawal rate. One thing I would not recommend for most people is counting on a 12% return and taking an 8% distribution. If you don’t believe me, try doing a Monte Carlo analysis to see what your results will be.

Will you take a steady withdrawal in retirement?

Studies on retirement withdrawals are interesting and provide a lot of good data, but in reality, many people don’t take a consistent withdrawal in retirement. For example, what if a couple retires at the age of 60 and doesn’t plan to take Social Security until age 67 or even 70? They will likely need to take a much larger withdrawal from their investments until they start collecting Social Security. For FERS retirees there are good reasons to consider that, which I cover in FERS retirees may want to delay Social Security.

What about the couple that wants to travel the world in their first five to ten years of retirement? They will likely need to take a larger withdrawal for their early retirement years.

Summary

Please do not base a retirement plan on an expected 12% return and an 8% withdrawal. Do your own due diligence or work with an advisor to come up with an appropriate investment allocation and continue to monitor it. A realistic plan is how federal retirees avoid running out of money. Withdrawal rates and Monte Carlo analysis are two elements that we analyze in our federal retirement planning. If you would like to schedule a call to discuss you can do so here.

Schedule a call

Sources

Dimensional Fund Advisors (DFA) Matrix Book 2018 (data through 2017). Large cap returns are from the S&P 500 Index and small cap returns are from the Dimensional U.S. Small Cap Index.

Brad Bobb, CFP®, Bobb Financial, is an expert in federal benefits and retirement planning for federal employees.

This article is for educational purposes only and is not individualized financial advice. Figures are illustrative.